Inside the Secret Facebook Group Where Women Review Men They've Dated

There aren’t suitable good single men living in New York City. That’s the way it is. everyone tells us. And when Deanna* moved into the city in the latter part of 2021 She was the next to check if there was an actual basis for the statement. Being single since the boyfriend she had been with for three years split with her via Snapchat, Deanna joined Hinge and Tinder. At this point, that a private Facebook page called Are we Dating the same Guy NYC became a must-follow. The group offered a thorough prescreen survey as well as guidelines for community members that served as a barrier to entry. It was also nearly 43,000 strong. Deanna was interested, and she joined.

The community

The group was founded in the exact purpose of helping women check if their love interests were actually seeing other people – was launched in March 2022. The majority of major US city has one of these groups now, and the rules for everyone are simple: Everyone is allowed to post anonymously, no doxxing or posting information that is sensitive, and in no circumstance can screenshots be deleted from the group. No bullies, no victim-blaming or hateful remarks. Never reveal to a man that he’s been a member of the group.you can find more here datingfortodaysman from Our Articles In the wake the scandal of West Elm Caleb, one man with whom a number of women in New York shared negative dating experiences and also connected the dots online, it became apparent that lots of women were in the market in search of a way to check out other people who were like him. A TikTok user was saying during the day This is why we need an app where we can leave reviews of guys we’ve dated on Hinge.

This is essentially what the group had turned into when Deanna joined. Every iteration of Are We Dating the Same Guy functions as a central area for women seeking romance advice or advise men whom they’ve had a bad relationship experiences. Loyalty-testing long-term boyfriends-that is it’s the act of contacting other women to attract them on social media-has also become common. It’s easy to fall down a rabbit through a maze of screenshots Hinge profiles, tales of hookups gone wrong, and memes of the flaws of modern-day dating. Some of the most popular posts include photos of a guy with his first name, asking the question of whether anyone has been matched to or dated the individual the person in question. Red-flag emoji are a frequent appearance on sporadic but alarming posts warning people of an ex-partner or bad experience frequently accompanied by a downward arrow, and the terrifying phrases See comments for more info.

The popularity of online dating has been a major factor in our chances in recent times, with one recent study revealing that around 39% of heterosexual couples met their partner online. It is therefore logical that the romantic aspect of romance will change in the digital age. Instead of talking to a handful of friends drinking a glass of wine or venting to coworkers, we are now seeking advice from 43,000 women going through similar-and in some cases exactly the same experiences.

It’s demystified this idea that dating is easier for some women than it is for others, says Ellie an additional group member. Not to say that there’s not privileges that exist, but it was certainly beneficial for me in terms of changing my notion of dating. There’s no competition for women with each other, however it is instead holding men to a higher quality than I did before.

It’s not lost on me that certain behavior which is encouraged and supported in Are We the Dating the Same Guy would be concerning if displayed by potential suitors. Photos, private conversations, and screenshots posted without the consent of the other party or knowledge are abundant. People dig up social media profiles on a regular basis. It’s easy for a potential date to be placed in the spotlight. Although Deanna enjoys being part group, she has some reservations. Sometimes you see people posting ‘If he wanted to, he would’ about paying for things or picking you up in an Uber, she adds. But I’m guessing that you’ll encounter the issue that it’s a echo chamber of men have got us in trouble for so long, now we’re going to give it right back.

We live in a patriarchal society

We are still the patriarchal system, and until we’re truly equal in our online interactions, they will result in different effects based on the individual’s background. Yet, can a community like this really have vigilante empowerment on one side of the spectrum and an abominable to the point of being incensed on the other? Are We All Dating the Same Guy? is hyperlocal and interconnected, which is only beneficial to those who live, and even date in the city the group is based in. The women, and the men they post about might be your neighbor your coworker, friend relatives, or even the most the most recent Hinge match. Yet, there’s a sense of depersonalization that happens when you use the internet, which makes it feel like playing it’s a game. It’s not an unreasonable idea to say this is objectifying on the dates that are part of both of these groups. This is especially true when details of private conversations, interactions and even photographs are made public without their approval or consent. Sometimes, it’s for pure entertainment.